Welcome back to the second half of my Fall Stitch Fix review. If you missed the first part of my post, just click the image below to catch up. I received an uber-chic black and white sweater, a comfy blue sweater that still somehow makes me look put together and a great knit blazer for fall. They were beautiful pieces and I can’t wait to tell you all about them.
This post contains affiliate links. We receive a small commission each time someone makes a purchase through one of our links. Thank you for supporting the blog – I hope you love this post as much as I enjoyed writing it.
Now are you ready to see what else came in my November Stitch Fix box?
Skien Quilted Puffer Vest
I was so excited to see that Layla had included the Skien Quilted Puffer Vest from Andrew Marc ($98) in my November Stitch Fix box. I’ve been searching for the perfect vest for over a year and I loved the idea of a puffer vest in a sharp red color.
I slipped the vest over a black and white striped top (similar here), my BlankNYC jeans (a closet staple!) and my black riding boots.
The vest was very cute, but it was a little larger on me than I wanted. I felt a bit like I was swimming in it. And the red was a little on the bright side. I’m still open to the idea of a red vest, but I think I would prefer a deeper shade of red in a more tailored fit. Sadly, the Skien Quilted Puffer Vest went back to Stitch Fix.
Henrietta Dress
The final item in my November Stitch Fix box was the Henrietta Dress from Maggy London ($118). This classic dress didn’t need very much help from me in the style department. I kept thing simple and wore it with a pair of round toe black patent leather heels, a string of pearls, and a Loren Hope cuff bracelet (similar here).
This dress was exactly my style. I love a fit and flare dress because they perfectly compliment my body type. This dress had great structure and was a perfect fit without any alterations. And the bold floral print, LOVE!
I love Maggie London dresses and I instantly searched around online to see if this dress is available outside of Stitch Fix. The good news is that YES, it is! The bad news is that it costs a lot more on the Nordstrom website (PS it also comes in petite).
It physically pained me to return this beautiful dress to Stitch Fix. Rob and I have zero dressy events on our calendar for the next several months, which is such a shame. I kept trying to talk myself into keeping it and I’m certain Rob was surprised that I had the willpower to return this beauty. It was that great of a dress!
If you love this dress as much as I do, you should go ahead an pin it right now. Then wear it somewhere special, post a photo online and please tag me. I would love to live vicariously through you!
What I Kept From My November Stitch Fix Box
My 42nd fix was another one for the books! Here’s a quick recap of what I decided to keep (and return) from my November Stitch Fix shipment.
Asa Knit Blazer from Skies are Blue ($68)-keep
Skien Quilted Puffer Vest from Andrew Marc ($98) –return
Genifer Tie-Back Knit Top from Loveapella ($58)-keep
Henrietta Dress from Maggy London ($118) -return
Mabel Button Detail Striped Pullover from Loveapella ($68) -return
Thanks to Brian from BTW Photography for taking such beautiful photos again this month!
How to Get the Best Clothes from Stitch Fix
Wondering how to make the most of Stitch Fix? I shared all of my best tips to help you get an amazing fix in this blog post. Stop by, take a few notes, and get ready for some seriously beautiful clothes to come your way!
Give Stitch Fix a Try
Just in case the clothes didn’t convince you to finally sign up for Stitch Fix and schedule your first fix, I’ll give you a few reminders about why I absolutely love this service.
- It’s free to sign up! Just login to StitchFix.com and create your free style profile.
- It’s convenient. When you are ready, schedule your first fix. For a $20 styling fee, you will be matched with a personal stylist who will hand-pick 5 items just for you and send them right to your door.
- You can try on the items at home. Mix and match the pieces you receive with the clothes you already own so you’ll be sure if they work for you.
- You can save 25%. That’s right! You automatically save 25% if you purchase everything that arrives in your fix.
Enter to Win a $50 Stitch Fix Gift Card
I love receiving my monthly Stitch Fix shipment and I want to share a little of that joy with you. We are giving away a $50 Stitch Fix gift card to one lucky reader. Use the Rafflecopter below for your chance to WIN!
Stitch Fix Link Up
If you are searching for more Stitch Fix inspiration for your Pinterest boards, you’ve come to the right place. Click any of the images below to read more recent Stitch Fix reviews from across the internet.

If you’re a blogger who loves to write about Stitch Fix, you are welcome to join the fun! Please make sure you post a recent Stitch Fix related post (less than 30 days old) and leave a link back to this page. Any links that do not follow the guidelines will be deleted.
That stripe sweater looks really great on you!
wwww.pearlsandsportsbras.com
That dress was amazing! I wouldn’t have kept it either without a good reason to wear it, but it was so great on you!
Why is the loveappella top called tie-back? does it have an interesting back?
Thanks for hosting another link up!
Hi Maria! I love the blue sweater paired with the top extender! I’m thinking of asking for a top extender for my birthday but I’m not sure what size I would need- do you mind sharing what size you wear? I think we have similar proportions. Thanks!
Hi Erin! The top extenders are pretty roomy and even have some stretch to them. I usually wear a small or medium in regular shirts and a small top extender fits with room to spare!
What a wonderful box of items Maria! I loved everything you kept and I think you look gorgeous in that dress you returned. ( though I totally hear you; sometimes all I need from my SF boxes is casual pieces.) Thanks for the link-up party. <3 XOXO, Elif
I got that vest in black last week and loved it!! The red is definitely very bright for you. I love my black. I hope you find one you like!!
What a great box! Everything looked great on you.
I love all the outfits they are super cute ?
That blazer looks great on you! The color is perfect. I’m sure the material will make it feel less dressy and more comfortable while managing a classroom of kindergarteners!
I love your slim black dress pants. The quality and fit looks perfect; just what I have been looking for to wear at work. By chance, do you have the name of the brand? Are they the ones by Express? Thank you! :)
Mine are from The Limited, but I found a similar pair at Express! Here is an affiliate link for the Express pants: http://rstyle.me/cz-n/b4gwqsbjbcf
Thank you for responding! It’s pretty awesome that you and Rob take the time to comment when you can. I really appreciate the info. and was so excited that The Limited was having a great sale and I found an amazing coupon code that saved me a ton of money on my purchase. I feel like I live vicariously through you guys (just kidding but not really). :)
Hi Crystal! We try to respond as often as possible and I’m so glad to hear that you got a great deal!
Cute!! I always come here for ideas to Pin for my SF requests.
I wish you had posted a picture of the back of the Tie-Back Knit Top (since it sounds from the name like that is where the detail is in that top)..
We love stitch fix and have been using them for years. If you have children try Wee Blessing as its pretty much stitch fix for kids! They style both boys and girls!
Great fix!! The blazer is great!
I just got my first Stitch Fix and it was great. I love the service! Looks like you had some great things in your box. I would have a hard time returning that dress – it’s just lovely!
Thank you for the link to that beautiful dress on Nordstrom. I just got my first SF box and was curious how the pricing was from them v’s independently. Glad to hear that they get some great deals and then pass them along!
You are very welcome. Sometimes the prices go the other way, but the Maggy London dress was a definite bargain!
Hi, Maria! I love following your stitch fix reviews! You have such cute clothes! I’ve recently started blogging my fixes with WordPress, but I can’t seem to pin my pictures with a link to my blog. The picture will pin, but that’s all you can see. Any tips? Thanks! https://stitchfixaddictblog.wordpress.com/2016/11/27/fix-4-november-2016/
It’s so funny to me that you didn’t keep that striped sweater, because I’ve had the photo of you wearing it pinned on my style board for at least a year at this point and STILL can’t find a sweater like it for my own closet. I found a similar Halogen sweater last winter, but it got a hole after the first washing. Such a bummer! :)
It’s so frustrating when you REALLY want something and it just doesn’t come your way. It’s also incredibly frustrating that the sweater you DID buy got a hole so quickly.